Critical Period for Bollworm Escapes on 2 Gene Cotton in AL

Ron Smith

Extension Entomologist, Auburn University

We are entering the most critical period of bollworm presence during the next 20 days (July 15-Aug 1). This increase in bollworm activity began last week (July 9-13) along the Gulf Coast and the Mobile/Santa Rosa County (Jay) FL area. By July 20^th, we should see an increased bollworm egg lay in Central AL (Montgomery, Prattville, Selma areas). By the 25^th this increase may reach Cherokee County in the northeast, and by August 1^st the Tennessee Valley area of northern AL.

Increased bollworm moth presence was noted last week as far north as Pike and Barber County (Troy) area. This increased moth activity will be influenced by the planting date and acreage of corn planted in a given region of the state. Most all bollworm were corn earworms in corn previous generation. This life cycle is about 30 days and the eggs in corn were deposited during the white or pink silk stge. About 30 days later these moths that emerged from corn are looking for their next host. Cotton is the best host they will find in AL (not soybeans or peanuts).

Many (but not all) fields in all areas of the state had more worm damaged bolls in 2017 than we had seen since 1995. If we want to prevent this from happening again, the next 2 weeks are critical.

I assume that most realize now that our 2 gene cotton has lost some level of effectiveness against the bollworm species. When resistance is a factor, the problem usually gets worse over time—it seldom gets better.

Now, what should fieldmen be looking for?

1.     Eggs in terminals or on the fruiting structures: square bracts, white or red blooms (threshold on 2 gene cotton is 20 eggs/100 plants)

2.     Damaged squares in the upper canopy – may find more damage to small squares near the terminal in Phytogen varieties (5% damage is threshold).

3.     Newly hatched larvae

May find in small squares in Phytogen varieties

May find more in open white blooms or underneath red or dried blooms in Delta Pine and other varieties

(5% of plants with small larvae is threshold)

These small larvae are white when they have just hatched and will turn pale green within a day or so.

One thing that makes them stand out in a white bloom is they will have a black or dark brown head. Often the head is the best thing to look for since being dark stands out from the white bloom petals. (See Picture)

Once a significant increase in eggs or small larvae are detected—do not waste more time in the field. Get the word to the grower and get the sprayer loaded. Every 24 hour period that passes from detection to treating means less effectiveness with your insecticide. Also note that these bollworm moths will likely seek out our oldest and most promising cotton to deposit eggs in.

Now what treatment options do we have? Basically two. We can try the older chemistry, pyrethroids, or we can go to the newer chemistry, Besiege and Prevathon.

Things to consider here: bollworms have shown levels of resistance to pyrethroids in many areas of the cotton belt. However, the pyrethroid chemistry is much less expensive. Pyrethroids have about a 4-5 day residual on bollworms, where they are still active.

The newer chemistry Beseige and Prevathon have about 10+ days of residual on bollworms, depending on the rate applied.

If using pyrethroids, I suggest the highest labeled rate. If using Beseige, I suggest 8-9 oz/ac. If using Prevathon, I suggest 16-18 oz/ac. Besiege contains a low rate of Karate pyrethroid in the mixture. If you need tarnished plant bug or stink bug control, you will need to add about 1 oz of additional Karate, or equivalent pyrethroid, to the tank mixture. Prevathon has no activity on plant bugs or stink bugs.

In summary, this is the time to be ready to react to bollworms in 2 gene cotton. I will be tweeting as I hear of increased pressure in a region, county, or area.

I will be conducting tests on thresholds, timing, and chemical choices at our research farm at Prattville in Central AL, so will be in the field a lot within the next 2 weeks or so.

Stay in touch with the Syngenta Pest Patrol reports for up to date observations on bollworms. To sign up for the Syngenta Pest Patrol Updates for Alabama, register online at syngentaus.com/pestpatrol or register via text by texting pestpat11 to 97063.

Twitter: @Ron_Smith23 https://twitter.com/Ron_Smith23?lang=en

Blog: http://alabama-insects.blogspot.com/

My Syngenta 800 line:

o   Call 1-877-285-8525: when prompted, press 1, then 2, then 4

Weekly email newsletter from Tim Reed containing moth trap data

o   Email reedtim@auburn.edu to be placed on this list

Thoughts and Tips for Bollworm Scouting on 2 Gene Cotton for 2018

          If you had an economic problem with escape bollworms on 2 gene cotton in 2017 and anticipate the problem in 2018, consider a 3 gene variety. Select one with similar maturity and yield potential as those you've been planting. This reduces acres scouts/consultants must focus on escape worms.

         When planting 2 gene cotton in 2018, monitor for bug and sucking pests and only make in-season foliar sprays when economic damage is found. This will conserve beneficial insects and reduce escape bollworms.

          If monitoring 2 gene cotton in 2018, take note of the corn planting window in your area. This plays a large role in the emergence & movement of corn earworm (bollworm) moths to cotton in July & Aug. The more corn planting is spread out, the wider the emergence window of bollworms.

          Bollworm moth activity isn't constant throughout the season. Instead it occurs in cycles especially through July. By August, generations of bollworms & tobacco budworms overlap. Fieldmen should detect the start of these peaks by focusing on eggs & newly hatched larvae in terminals/white blooms.

          Based on my observations during the Bt cotton era of the past 20 plus years, escape bollworm larvae do not feed on or damage as many fruiting sites per worm as they did in the pre Bt era.

          Scouting intervals for bollworms should be reduced to 3-4 days during critical windows on 2 gene cotton in 2018. Fieldmen may monitor select sentinel fields of similar variety and planting date to detect increased activity.

When monitoring for bollworm larvae or eggs on 2 gene cotton in 2018, be more concerned about detecting population increases early, and reacting if necessary, than quantifying exact numbers-- for example: 18 vs. 28 per whatever.

Fieldmen should consider damaged fruit on 2 gene cotton in 2018, but treatment decisions will be more timely if primary focus is on eggs and/or newly hatched larvae.

In order to stay on schedule in 2018, fieldmen should consider only staying in a field long enough to make a confident treat or not treat decision.

          Pest Patrol Updates on crop insects in Alabama available again in 2018. These alerts, sponsored by Syngenta, are beginning their 10th consecutive season. University entomologists discuss current conditions and advise on insect management.

        To sign up for the Syngenta Pest Patrol Updates for Alabama, register online at http://www.syngentaus.com/pestpatrol  or register via text message by texting pestpat11 to 97063.

Silverleaf Whitefly Control in Cotton

The silverleaf whitefly (SLWF) is a devastating economic pest of cotton. A multi-county area surrounding Tifton, GA was heavily infested in 2016. In 2017, this infested area has spread over much of the 1.3 million acres of cotton planted in Georgia. In early to mid August of 2017, these SLWF infestations have spread throughout the Wiregrass area of southeastern Alabama.

The SLWF was first observed on cotton in Alabama in Mobile county in 1997. This pest has historically been associated with the more arid regions of cotton production such as California, Arizona, and the Rio Grande Valley of southern Texas. Major outbreaks occurred in those areas in 1992 and 1993.

SLWF has sucking mouthparts and their feeding is similar to aphids. This feeding will stunt plants and reduce their vigor. However, a more serious problem is their secretion of honeydew, which falls in lower parts of the plant. This would be lower leaves during the growing season but open bolls as the plants mature. A sooty mold grows in this honeydew, which will reduce the quality of the lint once cotton begins to open.

Heavy infestations of SLWF can cause premature defoliation. SLWF are not known to die off from a naturally occuring fungus like aphids. SLWF populations continue to increase until cotton is defoliated or until the leaves drop from SLWF feeding.

The first sign of a SLWF infestation will be the presence of whiteflies clustering around the plant terminal or underneath the terminal leaves. The adults will fly when disturbed, Population increases will be observed about two plus weeks after the first presence of adults. SLWF adults deposit eggs underneath the leaves. These eggs hatch into a crawler stage which finds a place under the leaf to begin feeding. This immature stage is then immobile until it develops into an adult. The total life cycle of the SLWF is 15-18 days, depending on the temperature.

Treatment decisions for SLWF can be made by examining for the presence or absence of immatures on the 5th main stem leaf below the terminal. Controls are recommended when 50% of the plants have immatures on the lower surface of this leaf. Immatures will appear oval, flattened, and yellowish in color. They can be separated from aphids by their flattened shape and the absence of appendages and movement.

Points to remember about SLWF as expressed by Dr. Phillip Roberts, Extension entomologist, UGA: Do not overreact but be careful to not underreact to this pest. You cannot get behind with controls and ever catch up. Try not to do anything to make the situation worse. Do not treat for other pests unless necessary. When controlling other pests, use the most selective insecticides on beneficial insects. Cotton is not safe from SLWD damage until the day it is defoliated for harvest. Growers should try to get to defoliation time with green leaves in the plant terminal with no honeydew present.

Rainfall may reduce the number of adults but will have no effect on the immature stage underneath leaves. The damage potential from the SLWF is greatest on late planted cotton (late May-June). This pest prefers hairy leaf or semi-hairy leaf varieties over smooth leaf ones. Hot and dry conditions are favorable for more rapid SLWF reproduction.

Controlling SLWF in 2017 will be very expensive and challenging due to the unavailability or short supply of most recommended controls. The most effective control can be achieved with the insect growth regulator (IGR) type insecticides Knack or Courier. Both work on the immature stage. Their activity is slow but they have long residual. It is advisable to wait 10-14 days after treatment before making opinions about benefits.

Other products that have activity on the SLWF are acetamiprid (Assail/Intruder), Venom, and Sivanto. Centric at high label rates will suppress the adult stage.

Late July/Early August Cotton Insect Situation in Alabama

What are we currently finding in Alabama cotton fields? Plant bugs, both the tarnished and clouded species, have finally reached threshold or treatment levels in April planted fields that have not been sprayed. Some level of brown stink bugs can also be found in these same fields. A bug clean up spray would be advised for most cotton that is in the fourth or fifth week of bloom. Peak numbers of squares and bolls are currently at risk. Cotton planted after about May 10 missed most of the plant bugs this season. In central and south Alabama, there are very few plant bugs currently present in wild host or other crops. In other words, there are no more plant bugs in the landscape to migrate to cotton in 2017 in that region.

Between July 24 and 28, numerous field people from all areas of the state were contacted about escape bollworms on cotton with caterpillar technology. As of July 31, no none has reported any problems. We have conventional cotton on research stations in several areas of the state. Some level of bollworms and damage can be found on this cotton. The corn earworm flight from corn began about July 15 and has likely already peaked. Tobacco budworms will enter the mix during the month of August, but they will not be part of the "escape" situation in August. However, fieldmen should continue to monitor closely for escape bollworms. In Alabama, I would suggest we try the pyrethroid chemistry first if escapes are found.

Spider mites came into the picture about the third week of July in the Tenn. Valley area. Mites will likely show up in other fields statewide if we ever experience a 7-10 day period between rain events. Abamectin will provide the most economical control of mites. Whiteflies may occur in late season on our late maturing fields. If whiteflies are observed, I would recommend we use pyrethroid chemistry for stink bugs since Bidrin seems to aggravate the whitefly situation.

We will likely see stink bug numbers increase as we move into August and even September in our late maturing cotton. The southern green stink bug will make up a greater part of the population in coming weeks. This gives us the flexibility to choose either pyrethroid or phosphate chemistry. For weeks 3 through 6~7 of bloom, we recommend a 10% internal damage boll threshold for stink bugs.

Thus far in 2017, insects have not been a major limiting factor in Ala cotton production. Let's hope we can keep this trend going for several more weeks.

Rambling Thoughts About the 2017 Weather and Tarnished Plant Bugs in Cotton

I will say up front that no two seasons are exactly alike when considering the weather, crop conditions, and potential insect damage. 2017 has already been uniquely different than any season I remember. Delayed planting, excessive rainfall, mild winter, and warm spring are just a few of the factors that could affect the movement, numbers, and level of damage from plant bugs to this year's cotton crop. Only by close monitoring of plant bug numbers and their damage over the next 4-6 weeks will we know how to deal with this pest.

We need to begin sampling the oldest and largest cotton immediately with sweep nets for adult tarnished plant bugs. In addition, we should keep check on our square set by making pinhead square retention counts. 80% retention is considered our treatment threshold. In other words, we do not want to lose more than 20% of our small squares to plant bug damage.

If past history is any help, abundant to excessive rainfall in June tends to keep wild host plants like fleabane fresh a little longer. This slows or prolongs the movement of plant bugs into cotton. After fleabane dries down, no other wild host is attractive to adult plant bugs, therefore cotton is the best host they have. The movement of plant bugs into cotton has already begun. This migration could continue for several weeks. This slow extended migration may not reach what we would call a threshold or treatable level, making treatment decisions difficult. In hot, dry springs, these adult plant bugs leave fleabane in high numbers over a relatively short period of time, say 7-14 days. This sort of rapid movement into cotton is easier to detect and to make treatment decisions for.

There are a number of other factors that could influence the severity of the plant bug issue in cotton this season. Overall, I would estimate that the maturity of our cotton is a little behind where it normally is this time of year. Will plant bugs move past these fields in search of the oldest most mature cotton? April cotton may serve as a trap crop for plant bugs in 2017. That would be to our advantage. Since early June, we have had a lot of cloudy days with temperatures in the 70s or 80s. Plant bug survival on cotton has likely been higher under these conditions. This could spell higher damage levels in coming weeks. Plant bug adults, and especially their immature offspring, do not fare well under drought conditions and high temperatures (over 95°F), leaving cotton plants under a stressed and wilted condition.

Water logged spoils, which many fields have had during the month of June, can result in some pinhead square abortion. This effect would be very difficult to separate from plant bug injury. How can we distinguish this square loss from plant bug injury? The easiest way would be to use a sweep net to document that some level of plant bugs are actually in the field. One additional little trick that could help us answer this question was developed by our Arkansas entomology friends several years ago. This technique takes a little time, precision, and magnification. The tool needed would be a "pinhead square slicer." Take a damaged pinhead square from the plant (square will be brown or black in color), use a sharp razor, and slice the square in half. If it aborted due to weather, the inside content will still be present but deteriorating, whereas if it has been damaged by a plant bug, the interior will be hollow. Plant bugs tend to dissolve the contents and suck the interior of the square as food.

Plant bugs will likely be the primary cotton insect focus of entomologists, consultants, scouts, farmers, and other interested parties until well into July this season. We need to recognize this and not allow plant bugs to further limit our maturity and potential yield in 2017.

Update for the Week of August 4, 2014

The most significant insect event in the past week was the reports of plant bug tolerance to all labeled or recommended insecticides in the Tennessee Valley of North Alabama. Several of our most experienced consultants are reporting that all classes of chemistry are suppressing plant bugs but their presence and damage behind applications are still above threshold levels. This has required repeated sprays and now tank mixtures with two recommended insecticides. Under these conditions, input costs for cotton insects, particularly plant bugs, make cotton an unattractive crop option going into the 2015 season. Some areas of the mid-south have been dealing with this problem for several years. At this point, the Alabama situation appears to be confined to the Tennessee Valley area.

It has been my experience that once plant bugs get embedded in rank cotton in July, they have always been difficult to control, requiring multiple applications. So now, we have insecticide tolerance in addition to a coverage issue. Looking ahead I see a larger role for the IGR Diamond during the early bloom period in future years.

Now to a quick oversight of other insect problems on cotton and other crops; stink bugs, primarily brown, are requiring controls in some cotton fields. However, overall they are not as heavy and widespread as expected. Aphids are showing back up in some fields requiring controls. Spider mites are present in many fields. It seems like we get more calls about mite control following weeks of high temperature and dry conditions.

In soybeans we are beginning to see loopers as far north as Montgomery in older beans. So far they are only at about a third of a threshold level. Scouts are reporting an occasional corn earworm and velvetbean caterpillar in the soybean mix. The same holds true for peanuts.

Fall armyworms (grass strain) are on about every crop except cotton now. Hay, grasses, peanuts, soybeans are all experiencing the need for repeated applications for FAW. We could safely say that FAW’s have about worn out their welcome, even though they are easy to control. It seems like their preferred row crop is soybeans planted in wheat stubble. Some fields are now on their third infestation and replanting has been required due to near 100% defoliation.

In many ways, 2014 has been like “old times” to Extension entomologists with numerous phone calls about when to treat and what chemical to choose. We don’t feel like step-children to the weed resistance and disease issues this season.

Scouting crops is the first step in all insect management and control programs.

Insect Update for the Week of July 7

A combination of adult tarnished plant bugs and clumping aphids are being reported from more fields and areas around the state each day. Overall, little rainfall has fallen in about two weeks. Therefore, crops, especially corn and cotton, are under some level of stress. Therefore, most growers are choosing to target both plant bugs and aphids with this application.

I have not had any calls on mites in the past few days but that does not mean that populations are not building in select fields. So far, abamectin at 10 oz. per acre has given good control on mites in treated fields.

Immature plant bugs are present now in the oldest cotton. I have observed several fields where a threshold of three immatures per 5 feet has been recorded on a black drop cloth. When plant bugs become imbedded in cotton in July (all stages present – eggs, immatures and adults) quite often multiple applications are needed to bring the population under control. For those that want to use the IGR Diamond, now is the time to do so. An adulticide plus Diamond, at 6-9 oz. per acre, should give control of the population for 14 plus days. It is my opinion that most of the adult plant bugs have now left wild host plants and are now in cotton. We just don’t seem to get that many moving from corn here in Alabama.

Moth traps in central Alabama captured an abundant number of both bollworm and budworm moths last week. 2014 may be the year that fieldmen, consultants, and scouts really prove their worth. There is just no way to time the appropriate chemistry at the proper time without someone monitoring insects. This looks like an above average insect year for cotton and we haven’t even reached the primary stink bug window yet. In sweeping for adult plant bugs last week, I was capturing brown stink bugs in about every set of sweeps.

White Margined Borrower Bugs in Alabama

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  6m

   AL growers are still battling thrips on late planted cotton and peanuts. @on_agfax

   Expand

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  6m

   Immature WMBB have a red abdomen while the adults are black and about the size of adult plant bugs. @on_agfax

   Expand

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  7m

   Control of WMBB can be achieved with Bidrin. Pyrethroids give good suppression. @on_agfax

   Expand

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
4. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  7m

   WMBB usually associated with seeding crops growing under dry or droughty conditions. @on_agfax

   Expand

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
5. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  8m

   White margined burrower bugs (WMBB) are appearing at damaging levels on several row crops in AL. @on_agfax

   Expand

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 

Twitter Updates

Blog followers:

Following is a list of the information I have released this year (between mid January and late May) on Twitter. You can follow me on Twitter @Ron_Smith23 or look on the side bar of this blog to stay updated with my tweets year round.

1/15/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   The loss of methyl parathion registration may be felt early if corn population of #stinkbugs is primarily brown species. @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   First field crop generation of #stinkbugs in 2014 usually occurs in corn and may be mostly brown species. @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   Early season 2014 #stinkbug populations are likely to be predominately the brown species, which are more cold hardy @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
4. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   Insect species that may have been impacted by low temps were #kudzubugs and southern green #stinkbugs @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
5. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   Early January temps reached single digits in North AL and were as low as 14 degrees along the Gulf Coast.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
6. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Jan 15

   The recent (Jan 6-8) low temps in AL likely caused mortality to some overwintering insect species.

2/26/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Feb 26

   Thrips control in cotton is more important now in order to reach 3-5 bale yield potential of newer varieties. @AlabamaCrops

4/15/14:

1. 
   

   Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 15

   Thrips to be collected this spring, prior to and after exposure to cotton seed treatments, for resistance monitoring by @SyngentaUS.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 15

   Kudzu bugs active in Auburn, AL on April 12, a warm sunny day. @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 15

   Abundant moisture in April could influence similar delayed thrips movement into cotton from wild hosts, as in 2013. @AlabamaCrops

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
4. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 15

   Significant cotton planting will begin next week (April 21-26) in central Alabama, assuming dry conditions. @AlabamaCrops

4/28/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 28

   To register for "Pest Patrol" updates, go to http://www.syngentapestpatrol.com  and follow directions.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 28

   Insect conditions "Pest Patrol" program to be available again in 2014, sponsored by @SyngentaUS

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  Apr 28

   Grower concerns increasing about delayed cotton planting due to excessive moisture and frequent weather events.

5/1/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  May 1

   Both brown and southern green SBs found in wheat in several locations in central AL. Cold winter temps didn't suppress or kill as suspected.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  May 1

   Early stage adult tarnished plant bugs found on wild host plants in central Alabama. Late planted cotton more susceptible to TPB injury.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  May 1

   Thrips numbers remain low on wild host plants in central Alabama. Expect late movement to cotton as in 2013.

5/15/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  May 15

   Most of AL received from 1-5 inches of rain on May 14. Planting on hold until at least Monday, May 19.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  May 15

   Two true leaf cotton at Prattvillle AL had 1-2 thrips per plant on May 13, regardless of treatment. Little damage evident.

5/28/14:

1. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  2h

   Spidermites reported on 5/27 on cotton in the Eufaula area of SE AL.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
2. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  2h

   Reports of spidermites on both seedling cotton and soybeans in Tenn. Valley area of Alabama, consultants concerned.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
3. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  2h

   How long do acephate, dimethoate and Radiant need to be on plant for good thrips control? Four hrs b4 washoff showed little effectiveness.

   Expand
   

   •  Reply 
   •  Delete 
   •  Favorite 
4. Ron Smith ‏@Ron_Smith23  2h

   Significant increase in thrips numbers during week of May 19-23 in central AL. 50% are now immatures, which indicates in-field reproduction.